OK. So the title of this post is misleading.
There is nothing I hate about HIMYM! I love that show. I just finished watching all 9 seasons.
If you asked most people what they hate about HIMYM, they would say the ending. On IMDB the series has a rating of 8.3 but the final episode has a rating of 5.5, which is by far the lowest rating of the whole series.
I don’t hate the ending really, but if I was forced to criticise something about the show I would have to say:
- The last episode seemed a bit rushed. I think the could have taken a lot longer with this. Alyson Hannigan has said that there was a lot of great material for the finale and she was shocked at how much was cut
- I wish Barney could have had a happier outcome. But I guess the writers did their best with what they had
Since the premise of the story is that Ted is telling his kids how he met their mother, it is reasonable to assume that she might not be alive at that stage.
Having dealt with the bad, let me list my favourite things:
Barney is a fabulous character. I had watched a few episodes because my son was watching the show, and I think that Barney was (more than anything else) the thing that made me want to watch the show. He was so cool. He was (and there’s no way to avoid saying this) “legen … wait for it … dary!”
The device of having Ted telling the story to his kids gave the series a fabulous potential (which the writer exploited to the fullest) of time travel.
One example is that he was able to tell them that various girlfriends were NOT their mother. But he was also able to tell stories of near-misses with the mother, stuff about the umbrella, etc. It was great.
Another were the Rashomon elements in the story telling. In “Ted Mosby: Architect”, for example, Robin and Lily are hearing stories from various people of Ted seeming to act out of character.
Another was shown in “The Burning Beekeeper” where the same story is told again and again with different people filling in blanks from their perspectives.
Another was in the episode called “Dowisetrepla” where Marshall and Lily were shown saying this before Ted would say “is what he/she should have said” before showing what they actually said.
And then there was “We’re Not from Here” where Marshall and Lily write letters to each other to be opened upon the person’s death. But we jump far into the future to see one of them being opened.
And to further emphasise the time travel theme:
- In “The Time Travelers” Ted and Barney get advice from their future selves!
- Finally, in “The Window”, Marshall sends a letter to his future self and then future Marshall makes an appearance in the bar to arrange wings for his former self.
All in all, the time travel was one of the cleverest, funniest and most novel things on the show.
Very, very funny
The main thing to like about the show was that the writing was so clever and the show was so funny.
I don’t think there was an episode where I didn’t laugh out loud at some stage.
One of the funniest jokes, I think, was in “The Magician’s Code”. Lily was in hospital and in labour with Ted and Robin in the room when the following exchange happened:
Robin: That was not cool Ted.
Robin: That wasn’t cool Ted?
In conclusion, HIMYM is a great series. I may even watch it again!